Well since Tim had come in post Nida's lines earlier, no reason he couldn't reuse them.

"I was almost eaten by a tyrannosaurus rex, I was the best ballroom dancer in my class, and I once used magic to hold back a tide for an hour."

Two unbelievable, one believable. Do with that what you would, Tim. Which would be more interesting with Tim because Nida had mentioned moon monsters to him before. Would a T-Rex count?