"So... normally," if 'going to Wonderland' can be considered a normal event, "you wouldn't remember either, and we wouldn't be having this conversation?" He shakes his head a little, frowning. It's not that he doesn't believe her, exactly, but it doesn't make any sense to him. There would be no possible way to verify that it had or hadn't happened. Is that the point? Kind of like whatever is happening here, where they've been kidnapped by some entity for... what? Amusement?