Well, here he is talking about 'the other Matt' like it's an everyday occurrence to... what, discuss 'alternate realities' and redheaded doppelgangers? If he hadn't come out of a fountain a bit over a month ago Matt would be asking if Kurt had left his tinfoil hat at home.

As it is, anything is possible, and Matt's trying to keep an open mind.

"Oh." Yeah, Matt's familiar with the idea of coming back from the dead. It hadn't been pleasant and it's not an experience he would like to repeat any time soon. Thankfully his didn't involve quite as much paperwork.

"So you know another version of me." Forgive him. He's usually not this slow. "And he's... somehow also ended up blind and becoming a lawyer?" Doesn't sound like a very different outcome to Matt. Actually it sounds pretty shitty, like the universe has it out for him.

"I suppose that part is God's will. Or something."