Finnick's aware that he's not particularly trusted in this place, and he's given people here little reason to think he's interested in anything except himself and Annie. There's nothing anyone can do about who they're stuck in here with, though, and if Finnick's going to work with anyone towards getting out of here, at least it's someone who's helped him in the past and never seems to have held his and Annie's unease with the people here against them.

So he follows her, and when he sees the candle, he bends and picks it up, careful to hold it steady to support the flame.

"You haven't needed any keys to the Inn before now, have you?" he asks. He doesn't remember anything about there being any -- after all, most of the places people are living now hadn't been locked at all or nobody would have gotten into them without breaking either the door or a window. But Kate Kelly's been here longer than he has, so he's aware that there might have been something about keys before he arrived.